It’s hard driving green

We just bought a new car. It was a frustrating experience, but not for the usual reasons. We got a good deal, the color wasn’t an issue, and the salesperson seemed a decent guy. The car is a manual Hyundai Sonata sedan with an EPA rating of 22 City / 32 highway. It’s highly rated and appears to be a good buy, but it isn’t nearly as green as I would have liked.

Here was our problem: small cars like the Toyota Prius, Honda Civic (hybrid or not) and Hyundai Elantra get excellent mileage, but just don’t have enough rear seat leg room for our two growing teenagers. So, not an option. The car that really fits my needs (and more visceral wants) is the VW Jetta TDI, a turbocharged diesel that gets terrific mileage. Yes, diesel fuel is expensive at the moment compared to gasoline, but great fuel economy offsets part of that. And, when gas prices go up, diesel gets more attractive. As someone who cares about sustainability, I am willing to pay somewhat more for fuel if I can generate less carbon dioxide.

Ultimately, what knocked the Jetta out of the box was price; about $8,000 more than the Sonata, even taking into account the $1300 Federal tax credit for clean-burning diesels. There weren’t viable alternatives: VW, BMW and Mercedes produce the only diesel cars available today in the US. And, the Toyota Camry hybrid is also relatively expensive and doesn’t get mileage that much better than its conventional sibling.

Why don’t we have more choices? According to a Forbes article in the fall, “Between now and 2011, Acura, Nissan, Hyundai and Kia all plan to launch clean-diesel cars of their own.” Does it have to take that long? Estimates from auto experts are that 50-60% of new cars sold in Europe are diesels. I believe it; every car I’ve rented there over the past six years has been a diesel, many of them Fords, GMs and Toyotas. The engineering changes needed to accommodate minor differences in US-produced ultra low sulfur diesel can’t be that daunting.

The issue of high-priced diesel fuel in the US remains an issue, but one that should resolve. If gas prices do go back up, the economy advantage of a diesel will skew the cost delta back toward the diesel. As people start to buy and drive more diesels, the oil companies will certainly increase supply, helping to drive down prices, at least from that side of the supply and demand equation. And, today, a relatively low percentage of “gas stations,” at least where I live in the northeast, offer diesel, so there’s little price competition between outlets. Diesel drivers, I suspect, are just happy to find their fuel. That should change, too, as the number of diesel-powered vehicles goes up.

We’re seeing an emerging market thirst for cars with better mileage. Part of GM, Ford and Chrysler’s travails stem from their years of ramping up production of gas guzzlers. Giving US consumers access to what’s been available in Europe for years would be one expedient answer to the problems of the US auto industry. Maybe that should be a condition of any bailout package.

– Posted by Tom Witkin

Tagged with: , , , ,
Posted in Blogroll, Energy, Tales From the Road, Uncategorized
4 comments on “It’s hard driving green
  1. Hi there,

    I looked over your blog and it looks really good. Do you ever do link exchanges on your blog roll? If you do, I’d like to exchange links with you.

    Let me know if you’re interested.


  2. Tom Witkin says:

    The NY Times reported 1/5/09 that “Sales at Ford and G.M. in December Fall More Than 31%…for all of 2008, Ford’s sales fell 20.7 percent…while G.M.’s sales were down 22.9 percent…Smaller carmakers fared slightly better. Volkswagen sales fell 14 percent last month and 3.2 percent for the full year.”

    Looks as if I wasn’t the only one pining for the Jetta TDI.

    Another piece in the same paper noted that “Ford is retooling three former truck factories so they can make compact and subcompact cars.”

    Better late than never or too little too late?

  3. Robbin Smart says:

    I hear you. I spent a few months going through the same process and came up with a Mitsubishi Outlander. It was the best I could do. I was looking at several cars and SUV’s. The hybrid SUV’s were out of my price range. I was disappointed with the choices. My car rates a 6 for emissions and economy. I average 25 mpg, but even my Oldsmobile was better than this and it was a quality car. Here is an interesting car Imagine the sticker price on this car.

    In my opinion the bailout is another example of stupidity. Imagine the money the USA government could have given the citizens to choose the kind of car we should buy. I wonder, would this have stimulated the failing auto industry?

  4. Clean Diesel says:

    Yes, diesel fuel is expensive at the moment compared to gasoline, but great fuel economy offsets part of that. And, when gas prices go up, diesel gets more attractive.Nice article.Thank you.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s

Contact Info
m: 978-618-0377 / h: 978-443-0975
%d bloggers like this: